China plus one in practice: the five checks that pick the second origin per HTS line
China plus one is decided per HTS line, not per country. Five checks pick the second origin for each part: duty stack, freight mode, sub-supply, rule of origin, Section 232. Worked on a gasket that moves and an enclosure that stays.
A China plus one program is not a decision to add a country. It is a set of decisions, one per HTS line, about whether a second origin can beat the incumbent on landed cost and be qualified for that specific part. Five checks make that decision, in a fixed order, and the same five produce “move” for one part and “stay” for the next from the same buyer.
This post works the five checks. The wider decision, including when the right answer is nearshoring and when it is to stay in China with a better inspection plan, is in how to choose a sourcing origin per part. The program itself, from RFQ to a second source that has shipped twice, is on the China plus one page. All rates below are as of September 26, 2026 and confirmed per HTS code in the re-quote.
Check one: the duty stack per HTS line
The first check is arithmetic, and it eliminates more candidates than any other. Pull the 8-digit HTS code from the broker’s entry summary and read the stack at each origin.
From China a part pays MFN plus the Section 301 list rate (25% on Lists 1–3, 7.5% on List 4A, nothing if unlisted) plus the 12.5% from the July 24, 2026 Section 301 action: 37.5 points above MFN on List 1–3 parts, 20 on List 4A, 12.5 on unlisted goods. From other origins it pays MFN plus 12.5% (10% for some economies), unless the goods are FTA-qualifying, in which case MFN is waived and no Section 301 applies. A part that fails its rule of origin pays MFN plus 10%.
| Class of part | China | Alt. origin · 12.5% duty | Alt. origin · FTA, 0% | Duty gap to a 12.5% origin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 301 Lists 1–3 | MFN + 37.5 points | MFN + 12.5 | 0% | 25 points |
| List 4A | MFN + 20 points | MFN + 12.5 | 0% | 7.5 points |
| Unlisted | MFN + 12.5 | MFN + 12.5 | 0% | None |
On an unlisted part the gap to a 12.5% origin is nil, and only an FTA-qualifying origin changes the duty line. On a List 3 part it is 25 points before the FTA even enters. That right-hand column tells you which lines are worth the other four checks.
Check two: freight mode, transit and the lot size it forces
The second check is how the part travels and what that does to the per-unit cost, the cash tied up in transit and the order quantity.
An ocean origin ships the way China does: roughly the same cost per container, 30–45 days on the water, and economics that push toward full containers and quarterly releases. An origin within truck range of the US ships in days, in pallets, on a schedule that can track demand. Freight belongs on the sheet per unit, never per container. As an illustration with round numbers, a $5,000 container holding 100,000 small gaskets costs 5 cents a unit to move; the same container holding 5,000 bulky enclosures costs $1.00 a unit.
The transit line also carries working capital. Goods on the water are paid for and unsellable, and long, variable transit means more safety stock at your warehouse. The check matters most on bulky, low-value parts, where freight is a large share of landed cost, and on parts whose demand moves, where monthly releases are worth a few cents a unit.
Check three: where the sub-supply lives
The third check asks what actually moves when the last operation moves. If the resin, the printed circuit board, the plating line or the fastener kit ships in from China whatever the final factory’s address, then moving the final factory moves less than the quote implies.
It moves less cost, because the imported inputs still carry their own freight and lead time. It moves less risk, because a disruption upstream reaches both factories. And it may move nothing on the duty line, because a part assembled in an FTA-qualifying origin from non-originating inputs can fail the rule of origin and pay MFN plus 10% instead of 0%.
Mapping the sub-supply before quoting is the only way to know which case you are in. Electronics and complex assemblies, where five sub-vendors sit within a bus ride of the final factory in Guangdong, are the classic case where the sub-supply stays and the part should too.
Check four: the rule of origin as a traceability file
The fourth check turns the 0% in the table into something you can defend at entry. A rule of origin is written per HTS heading in the agreement’s annex: a tariff shift, a regional value content threshold, or both. The importer claims the preference and carries the burden of proving it, with records that trace each input back to its source and its classification.
Treat the check as building a file, not ticking a box. The file lists each input, its supplier, its country of origin and its heading, and shows either that the non-originating inputs changed heading in the FTA territory or that regional content clears the threshold. The same bill-of-materials trace is most of a UFLPA file, so it is built once and kept current for both purposes. The mechanics of tariff shift and regional value content, and what the file has to hold, are in rules of origin, explained.
If the file cannot be built for a part, the FTA origin is priced at MFN plus 10% for that part and the comparison is re-run before anything else happens.
Check five: Section 232
The fifth check is a screen for metal content. Since June 8, 2026, Section 232 applies at 50% to articles essentially all steel, aluminum or copper and at 25% to derivatives substantially made of them, on full customs value, at any origin, through December 31, 2027. Under 15% metal content is exempt. Section 232 goods do not also pay the 12.5% or 10%, and an FTA waives MFN but not Section 232.
For a metal part, then, the surcharge is the same at every origin and the only duty difference left is the China list rate, where the heading is listed. The second origin for a bracket or a housing is chosen on lead time, MOQ, freight and the quality system, not on the 12.5%. The screen runs early because it changes what the other four checks are for.
The five checks on two parts
Run on the gasket, the checks say move. Molded EPDM gasket, HTS 4016.93.50 (MFN 2.5%, List 3), 120,000 units a year, single-sourced in China at $1.20 FOB, freight to Dallas. Check one: 40.0% from China against 15.0% from a 12.5% origin and 0% from an FTA-qualifying one. Check two: half the freight at the near origin. Check three: a single-material molded part, so the sub-supply question is one input rather than five. Check four: the rule of origin for the heading holds once documented. Check five: no metal content.
| Per unit | China | Alt. origin · 12.5% duty | Alt. origin · FTA, 0% |
|---|---|---|---|
| FOB | $1.20 | $1.26 | $1.38 |
| Duty | $0.48 (40.0%) | $0.19 (15.0%) | $0.00 (0%) |
| Freight | $0.06 | $0.07 | $0.03 |
| Landed | $1.74 | $1.52 | $1.41 |
| Our fee, 10% of FOB | — | $0.13 | $0.14 |
| All-in | $1.74 | $1.65 | $1.55 |
| Annual, all-in | $208,800 | $197,520 | $185,760 |
Net saving at the best origin: $23,040 a year, 11% after the fee. The 12.5% origin nets $11,280 (5.4%).
Run on the injection-molded PP enclosure, HTS 3926.90.99 (MFN 5.3%, List 4A), the checks say stay. Check one gives a 7.5-point gap to a 12.5% origin instead of 25, and the part lands $2.77 from China, $2.79 from a 12.5% origin and $2.50 from an FTA-qualifying origin; after the fee the net is under 1%. The recommendation is a better inspection plan at the factory the buyer already has. The other kinds of part that stay, and the arithmetic behind each, are in when China still wins.
Same buyer, same molding process, same re-quote: one line moves, one stays. That is what per-HTS-line means in practice, and why the second origin is a column on a sheet rather than a country on a slide.
What to do with this
- Classify each active part by HTS code as Lists 1–3, List 4A, unlisted or Section 232. Only the first group is worth all five checks on duty alone.
- Map the sub-supply for the List 1–3 parts before requesting a quote: where the resin, board, plating and hardware come from today.
- Run the survivors through the landed-cost calculator, then get factory-level quotes with the rule-of-origin check and the fee on the sheet. How the ten business days are spent is on the process page.
Want this run on your parts? Send up to five SKUs and you’ll have a landed-cost comparison — China and other countries, named factories — in ten business days. No fee, no obligation.