Guide · Choosing an origin
· 15 min read · china plus one · nearshoring · tariffs

China plus one, nearshoring, or staying put: how to choose a sourcing origin per part

Choosing an origin per part at the 2026 tariff stack: classify the HTS line, run landed cost with the fee, prove the rule of origin, keep China where it wins, add a second source without moving tooling, re-run quarterly.

This guide is for the buyer who has been told to “diversify out of China”, “nearshore” or “stand up a China plus one program” and now has to turn that sentence into purchase orders. It covers the whole decision for one part at a time: which parts are candidates, how the origins compare at the tariff stack in force as of September 26, 2026, what has to be proven before a 0% rate is real, when the right answer is to stay where you are, and how to keep the decision current. Every rate below carries that date and is confirmed per HTS code before it reaches a quote.

The one-sentence answer: the origin is chosen per part, on landed cost at the current stack with the agent fee included, and across a bill of materials the result is a mix rather than a country. Some lines move to an FTA-qualifying origin, some to a 12.5% origin, some stay in China, and some stay in China and gain a second factory.

Three labels, one decision

“China plus one”, “nearshoring” and “staying put” are usually presented as strategies a company picks between. They are better understood as outcomes that a single method produces, part by part.

Nearshoring means an origin within truck range of the US: truck freight in days instead of 30–45 on the water, smaller lots, and 0% duty where the part is FTA-qualifying. The definitions and the trade-offs are on the nearshoring page. China plus one means a second, audited source alongside the Chinese factory you already have, with China kept wherever it still wins; the program is laid out on the China plus one page. Staying put means keeping the incumbent, usually with a better inspection plan than it has today.

None of these is right for a company. Each is right for some parts. The same buyer, in the same re-quote, can have a gasket that moves to an FTA-qualifying origin, an enclosure that stays in China, and a bracket that stays in China but gains a second factory in another province. The strategy is the sum of those lines.

The takeaway: stop asking which strategy and start asking which part. The rest of this guide is the per-part method.

Start with the class of part, not the country

The first sort costs nothing. Pull the 8-digit HTS code from your broker’s entry summary and place the part in one of four classes, because the class fixes the size of the duty gap between origins before any factory is contacted.

As of September 26, 2026, a China-origin part pays MFN plus the Section 301 list rate in place since 2018 and 2019 (25% on Lists 1–3, 7.5% on List 4A, nothing on unlisted headings) plus the 12.5% from USTR’s July 24, 2026 Section 301 action.1 That is 37.5 points above MFN on List 1–3 parts, 20 on List 4A and 12.5 on unlisted goods. Other origins pay MFN plus 12.5% (10% for some economies) since July 24, unless the goods are FTA-qualifying, in which case MFN is waived and no Section 301 applies. Section 232 metals, since June 8, 2026, pay 50% or 25% at any origin instead of the 12.5% or 10%.

Class of partChinaAlt. origin · 12.5% dutyAlt. origin · FTA, 0%Duty gap that can pay for a move
Section 301 Lists 1–3MFN + 37.5 pointsMFN + 12.50%25 points to a 12.5% origin; MFN + 37.5 to an FTA origin
List 4AMFN + 20 pointsMFN + 12.50%7.5 points to a 12.5% origin; MFN + 20 to an FTA origin
Unlisted (List 4B, never imposed)MFN + 12.5MFN + 12.50%None, unless the origin is FTA-qualifying
Section 232 metals (since June 8, 2026)MFN + list rate + 232 at 50% or 25%MFN + 232 at 50% or 25%232 at 50% or 25% (MFN waived)The China list rate only; 232 is paid everywhere

Read the right-hand column. A List 1–3 part is a candidate to move on duty alone. A List 4A part needs the arithmetic done, because a higher factory price eats 7.5 points quickly. An unlisted part changes only if an FTA-qualifying origin is in play. A Section 232 part is a lead-time and MOQ decision, because the surcharge follows it to every origin.

The full line-by-line treatment of landed cost, from FOB through duty, freight and the fee, is in the landed-cost guide for importers. This guide assumes it and concentrates on the choice between origins. The takeaway: classify every part before you shortlist any country.

The landed-cost test every origin has to pass

Once a part is classified, each candidate origin is priced the same way: FOB, duty at the real stack for the code, freight per unit to your dock, and the agent fee on every alternative. Landed cost is the first three lines; all-in cost is all four. The honest comparison is the incumbent’s landed cost against each alternative’s all-in cost.

The gasket shows what that does. Molded EPDM gasket, HTS 4016.93.50 (MFN 2.5%, List 3), 120,000 units a year, currently single-sourced in China at $1.20 FOB, freight to Dallas. Rates as of September 26, 2026, confirmed per HTS code.

Per unitChinaAlt. origin · 12.5% dutyAlt. origin · FTA, 0%
FOB$1.20$1.26$1.38
Duty$0.48 (40.0%)$0.19 (15.0%)$0.00 (0%)
Freight$0.06$0.07$0.03
Landed$1.74$1.52$1.41
Our fee, 10% of FOB—$0.13$0.14
All-in$1.74$1.65$1.55
Annual, all-in$208,800$197,520$185,760

China duty is MFN 2.5% plus List 3 at 25% plus the July 24 layer at 12.5%, 40.0% in total. The 12.5% origin pays 15.0%. The FTA-qualifying origin pays nothing once the rule of origin is documented for the heading. Net saving at the best origin: $23,040 a year, 11% after the fee; the 12.5% origin nets $11,280 (5.4%). The winning origin’s factory price is 15% higher than China’s and it does not matter, because the duty line is 48 cents against zero and the freight line is half.

The method has to be able to say no as well. An injection-molded PP enclosure, HTS 3926.90.99 (MFN 5.3%, List 4A), from the same buyer lands $2.77 from China, $2.79 from a 12.5% origin and $2.50 from an FTA-qualifying origin. After the fee the net is under 1%, and the recommendation is to stay in China. The comparison itself, including transit working capital, safety stock, MOQ and tooling, is worked through in nearshoring versus offshoring in 2026, and you can test a part of your own in the landed-cost calculator before anyone quotes anything.

The takeaway: no origin is chosen until all four lines are filled in for every origin, and the fee sits on its own line.

The five checks that pick a second origin

Landed cost ranks the origins. It does not by itself tell you whether a second origin can be stood up for this part. Five checks do, and they run in a fixed order for each HTS line.

The first is the duty stack per HTS line, which is the class table above applied to the code. The second is freight mode and transit: ocean transit like China, or truck freight in days, with the per-unit freight, the working capital in transit and the lot size the mode forces on you. The third is where the sub-supply lives. If the resin, the board, the plating line or the fastener kit comes from China anyway, moving the last operation moves less than it appears to, in cost, in risk and in the rule-of-origin test.

The fourth is the rule of origin, treated as a traceability file rather than a checkbox: tariff shift, regional value content or both, read for the part’s heading and documented input by input. The fifth is Section 232. If the part is more than 15% steel, aluminum or copper by content, the 50% or 25% follows it to every origin, an FTA waives MFN but not Section 232, and the second source is chosen on lead time, MOQ and the China list rate rather than on the surcharge.

Each check can eliminate an origin on its own. Each is worked on the gasket and the enclosure in China plus one in practice: the five checks that pick the second origin. The takeaway: run the five checks in order and let a failed check end the discussion for that origin.

Rules of origin: the 0% is earned per part

The FTA column in every table above says 0%, and that figure is the largest single reason a part moves. It is also the easiest to get wrong, because 0% is not a property of a country. It is a property of a part that meets the rule of origin written for its HTS heading in the agreement, and the importer, not the factory, has to prove it.

Rules of origin take two general forms. A tariff-shift rule requires the non-originating inputs to be classified under a different heading, or chapter, from the finished good, so that the work done in the FTA territory amounts to a real transformation. A regional value content rule requires a stated share of the part’s value to come from within the agreement’s territory, measured by a formula the agreement sets. Some headings require one, some the other, some both. A part made in an FTA-qualifying origin from inputs that mostly ship in from China can fail either.

The consequence of failing is not a return to the China rate. As of September 26, 2026, a part from an FTA-qualifying origin that does not meet its rule pays MFN plus 10%, confirmed per HTS code. On the gasket that is the difference between landing at $1.41 and landing above the 12.5% origin’s number, with the 15% FOB premium still in place. The mechanics, the importer’s burden of proof and the records that back a claim are in rules of origin, explained.

The takeaway: an FTA origin goes on the shortlist only after the rule for the specific heading has been read and the bill of materials checked against it.

When China still wins

A re-quote that never recommends staying in China is selling you a move. Four kinds of part stay more often than they go, and naming them keeps the decision from becoming a reflex.

Parts whose sub-supply lives in China: electronics and complex assemblies where the connectors, boards, plating and hardware are all sourced within a day’s drive of the final factory. Parts whose tooling is still iterating, where a toolmaker and a molder in the same province turn a revision in days. Parts on List 4A or unlisted headings, where the duty gap to a 12.5% origin is 7.5 points or nothing and a higher factory price erases it, as the enclosure showed. And Section 232 metals, where duty is 50% or 25% from everywhere and the remaining difference is the China list rate against freight and lead time.

A fifth case is size rather than kind. On a program under roughly $50,000 a year, the cost of qualifying a second factory can exceed the duty saved, whatever the class. The four kinds, with the arithmetic behind each, are in when China still wins.

Staying in China is a decision about the country, not about the factory. Some of these parts should still change factories, or add one, if the incumbent has never been audited. The takeaway: “stay put” is a valid output of the method, and it should arrive with an inspection plan attached.

A second source without betting the tooling

The commonest reason a sound origin decision never becomes a purchase order is tooling. The mold or die lives at the incumbent, the incumbent made it, and nobody is sure who owns it. Moving it risks the only tool that makes the part; leaving it means the second source needs a second tool, which costs money and validation time.

The way through is to separate two decisions. First, title: a tooling-hold agreement with title to you and a tooling ownership letter on file, at every origin, so that moving a tool is a logistics question rather than a negotiation. Second, sequence: the second source runs in parallel through audit, samples and a pilot order while the incumbent keeps shipping, and no volume moves until the second factory has delivered twice to spec. For engineered parts that means a first-article inspection against the ballooned drawing; for catalog goods, a golden sample approved and retained by you, by the agent and at the factory.

The pilot is where the second source proves itself: an in-process check partway through the run and an AQL pre-shipment inspection on packed goods, with the report in your hands before the container leaves. How those gates sit inside the ten-business-day quote and the weeks that follow is on the process page, and what each inspection covers is on the quality inspection page. The staging, the tooling clauses and the duplicate-tool arithmetic are in how to qualify a second source without betting your tooling.

The takeaway: own the tool wherever it lives, and let the incumbent cost a quarter or two of extra duty rather than move volume to a factory that has shipped once.

Compliance that is not on the duty line

One item in the origin decision carries no rate at all and can stop a shipment regardless of what the shipment paid. UFLPA is CBP’s import prohibition and detention regime. It is a traceability obligation, not a tariff: a detained entry is released on evidence about where the inputs came from, not on payment of anything.

This matters here for two reasons. The first is that the July 24, 2026 action is sometimes described as a forced-labor tariff, and it is not. It is a Section 301 duty, collected at entry, and USTR’s stated basis for it belongs in a footnote. UFLPA is separate and applies whatever duty the goods pay. The second is practical: the bill-of-materials trace you build to prove a rule of origin, input by input back to the raw material, is most of a UFLPA file, so it should be built once and kept current for both.

Any origin can be asked for that file, China included, because the question is where the inputs came from rather than where the last operation happened. The detention mechanics, what a traceability file contains and how it differs from a duty are in UFLPA is not a tariff. The takeaway: budget the traceability file into the origin decision at every origin, and do not confuse it with the 12.5%.

The decision is dated: the quarterly origin review

Every number in this guide carries September 26, 2026, and that date is a working part of the method. The stack changed four times this year: the Supreme Court struck the IEEPA reciprocal and fentanyl tariffs on February 20, a 10% Section 122 surcharge ran from February 24 to July 24, the Section 232 metals regime was reset on June 8 through December 31, 2027, and the Section 301 action took effect on July 24. A second Section 301 investigation, on excess capacity across 60 economies, opened in March 2026 and is still open.

An origin decision made on one of those dates and never revisited is a decision made on rates that may no longer exist. The remedy is a quarterly origin review: re-run the landed cost on every active part at the current stack, with current freight and the current rule-of-origin status, and read it against a monthly scorecard of on-time delivery, defect rate and landed cost versus baseline. The output is per line: hold, move, add a second source, or move back.

The review is cheap because the sheet already exists. The quote that chose the origin and the review that confirms it are the same document with new dates. How to set one up, what triggers an out-of-cycle review and how to read it with a CFO are in the quarterly origin review. The takeaway: a sourcing decision is re-earned each quarter, not made once.

Putting it together: the rule per part

The method reduces to a rule that fits on an index card, and it is the same rule whether the label on the project is nearshoring, China plus one or cost reduction.

Classify the part by HTS code. Run China and the viable alternative origins at the real stack for that code, with freight per unit and the agent fee on every alternative. Apply the five checks and drop any origin that fails one. Then decide. If an origin lands 10% or more below the current cost, pursue it, starting with the rule of origin and the tooling. If two origins land within 5% of each other, decide on lead time, MOQ and risk rather than price. If nothing beats the incumbent by 5%, keep the incumbent, fix the inspection plan, and consider a second factory in China for resilience rather than cost.

Class and situationTypical findingLikely outcome
Lists 1–3, rule of origin holds, sub-supply portableDouble-digit gap after the feeMove to the FTA-qualifying origin; incumbent ships until the second source has shipped twice
Lists 1–3, no FTA origin qualifiesMid-single-digit gap to a 12.5% originMove if demand is stable and container-sized; otherwise China plus one
List 4A or unlistedUnder 5% either wayStay in China; fix inspection; add a second Chinese factory if single-sourced
Section 232 metalDuty near-identical at every originDecide on lead time and MOQ; put a domestic quote on the sheet
Any class, sub-supply in ChinaRule of origin at risk; saving overstatedStay, or move only the lines whose inputs move with them
Any class, under roughly $50,000 a yearQualification cost exceeds duty savedStay; audit the incumbent

The table is a guide to where the arithmetic tends to land, not a substitute for running it. The gasket and the enclosure sit two rows apart with the same buyer and the same molding process. The takeaway: the rule is mechanical and the inputs are not, which is why a quote names the HTS code, the date and the factory.

What to do with this

  1. List the top five parts by annual spend with their 8-digit HTS codes, from your broker’s entry summaries, and classify each as Lists 1–3, List 4A, unlisted or Section 232.
  2. Run the List 1–3 parts through the landed-cost calculator with conservative FOB premiums (5% and 15% above China is the gasket’s pattern) and freight per unit by lane.
  3. For each part that clears 10%, read the rule of origin for its heading and check the bill of materials against it before shortlisting an FTA origin.
  4. Find out who owns the tooling at the incumbent, in writing. If the answer is unclear, that is the first thing to fix at any origin.
  5. Put a date on the sheet and a quarterly reminder next to it. The second Section 301 investigation is open and the Section 232 reset expires at the end of 2027.

Want this run on your parts? Send up to five SKUs and you’ll have a landed-cost comparison — China and other countries, named factories — in ten business days. No fee, no obligation.

Footnotes

  1. USTR’s stated basis for the 2026 Section 301 action was a finding on unenforced forced-labor import bans. It is a duty, collected at entry. It is not UFLPA, which is CBP’s import prohibition and detention regime, a traceability obligation rather than a tariff, and which applies regardless of what duty the goods pay. ↩

Free 10-day re-quote

Send us your top five SKUs. Get every viable origin back.

No commitment. In ten business days you’ll have a landed-cost comparison you can put in front of your CFO, with named factories behind every number.