Does a 10% sourcing fee pay for itself? The math on the gasket and the enclosure
On the gasket, a 10% fee costs $16,560 a year against a $39,600 landed saving and nets $23,040. On the enclosure it eats all but two cents a unit, so the part stays put. The break-even rule, worked by tariff class.
A 10% sourcing fee pays for itself when the landed saving at the new origin is larger than 10% of the new origin’s FOB plus the cost of switching, and not otherwise. On the gasket in our worked example the saving covers the fee 2.4 times over; on the enclosure from the same buyer it barely covers it at all, and the honest answer is to stay put.
This post runs both parts through that test with the fee on its own line, then turns the test into a break-even rule by tariff class. Rates are as of September 26, 2026 and confirmed per HTS code before they go on a quote. How the four lines of a landed-cost comparison fit together is in the landed-cost guide for importers, 2026 edition.
How the fee works
The fee is 10% of the FOB value on the factory’s commercial invoice, invoiced per purchase order, separately from the factory’s invoice. You contract with and pay the factory directly, at FOB, on the factory’s own terms. We never take title to the goods, never finance or warehouse them, and never put a margin inside the FOB price. There is no retainer, no setup fee and no minimum.
The fee covers the multi-origin RFQ, the factory audit, DFM review, first-article inspection, AQL pre-shipment inspection, logistics coordination, the compliance file and a quarterly origin review. Lab tests, certification, sample freight and tooling pass through at cost, approved by you in advance. The full terms are on the pricing page.
Two things follow for the math. Because the FOB you see is the FOB you pay, the fee can sit on its own line instead of hiding in the unit price. And because it is 10% of the alternative’s FOB, not China’s, it grows with any FOB premium the new factory charges.
The gasket: where the fee pays
Molded EPDM gasket, HTS 4016.93.50 (MFN 2.5%, Section 301 List 3), 120,000 units a year, freight to Dallas. From China it pays 40.0% duty: MFN 2.5%, the List 3 rate of 25% and the July 24 Section 301 tariff of 12.5%. It lands at $1.74 a unit, $208,800 a year.
| Gasket, 120,000 units a year | Alt. origin · FTA, 0% | Alt. origin · 12.5% duty |
|---|---|---|
| Landed saving vs. China, before fee | $39,600 | $26,400 |
| Our fee, 10% of FOB | $16,560 | $15,120 |
| Net to you | $23,040 | $11,280 |
| Net as a share of current cost | 11% | 5.4% |
Per unit, the FTA-qualifying origin lands at $1.41 against China’s $1.74, a 33-cent saving. The fee is 10% of its $1.38 FOB, just under 14 cents. That leaves 19 cents a unit, $23,040 a year, and the fee takes about four-tenths of the landed saving.
At the 12.5% origin the saving is 22 cents and the fee is just under 13 cents, so the fee takes nearly six-tenths of the saving and leaves $11,280. Both options pay. The first pays well; the second pays, but thinly enough that switching cost matters, which the payback section below works through.
The enclosure: where it doesn’t
Injection-molded PP enclosure, HTS 3926.90.99 (MFN 5.3%, List 4A), same buyer, same re-quote. China pays 25.3%, a 12.5% origin 17.8%, an FTA-qualifying origin 0%. Landed before the fee: $2.77 from China, $2.79 from the 12.5% origin, $2.50 from the FTA-qualifying origin.
The 12.5% origin loses before the fee is added. The FTA-qualifying origin saves 27 cents a unit landed, and the fee on its FOB is 25 cents. The net is 2 cents, under 1%.
That is not worth moving a part for. Two cents does not cover the switching cost or the risk of a new factory on a part that ships fine today. The re-quote says stay, and on a stay we earn nothing on that part. The better use of the effort is the inspection plan at the factory the buyer already has.
If the worry is single-source risk rather than cost, a second factory for the same part is a separate decision, the China plus one one. It should be justified on risk, not on this sheet.
The break-even rule, by tariff class
The test per unit is: the incumbent’s landed cost minus the alternative’s landed cost must exceed 10% of the alternative’s FOB, plus switching cost spread over the units. Leave freight and switching cost aside for a moment and the test becomes a single number: how much higher the new factory’s FOB can be before the fee eats the duty saving.
The arithmetic is China’s FOB × (1 + China duty) against the alternative’s FOB × (1 + alternative duty + 10%). On a List 1–3 part with a 2.5% MFN rate, that is 1.40 against 1.10 at an FTA-qualifying origin, so the alternative can charge up to 27% more and still break even.
| Class, MFN rate (illustrative) | China duty | Alt. origin · 12.5% duty | Alt. origin · FTA, 0% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lists 1–3, MFN 2.5% | 40.0% | FOB up to 12% above China’s | FOB up to 27% above China’s |
| List 4A, MFN 5.3% | 25.3% | FOB must be about 2% below China’s | FOB up to 14% above China’s |
| Unlisted, MFN 2.5% | 15.0% | FOB must be about 8% below China’s | FOB up to 4.5% above China’s |
Rates as of September 26, 2026, before freight and switching cost; a real part’s stack is confirmed per HTS code.
Read the gasket against the first row. Its FTA-qualifying factory quoted 15% above China, well inside 27%, and its 12.5% factory quoted 5% above, inside 12%. Both pay. The enclosure sits on the second row; in the illustrative inputs behind it, the FTA factory quoted about 17% above China, past the 14% line, and only a 9-cent freight saving pulled it back to 2 cents net.
The class decides more than the country does. Placing your own part in the right row, from the entry summary to the final percentage, is in how to read your tariff stack by HTS code.
Switching cost and payback
The fee recurs on every purchase order, so it belongs in the annual net, where the table above already has it. Switching cost happens once: samples, first-article inspection, re-certification where the standard requires it, and often a duplicate mold. The pricing page gives the pass-through ranges: $150 to $1,500 per lab test, $2,000 to $15,000 to certify a new product, $50 to $300 per sample shipment, tooling quoted per part.
Suppose, as an illustration, switching costs $20,000 once, most of it a duplicate mold. At the FTA-qualifying origin the gasket nets $23,040 a year, so it pays back inside a year. At the 12.5% origin it nets $11,280 a year, so payback takes about 21 months. At an illustrative 100,000 units a year, the enclosure’s 2 cents nets $2,000 a year and would take ten years.
We do not count inspection, audits or the quarterly origin review as savings on the sheet. They are what the fee buys, and the net has to stand without them. Below roughly $25,000 in annual FOB per part family, the fee does not cover a first program’s audit and inspection cost, and the re-quote says so.
What it costs to find out
The re-quote is free and takes ten business days from confirmed scope. You send up to five SKUs; you get a landed-cost comparison across China and other countries, named factories disclosed under NNN, the tariff stack per HTS code, the fee on its own line and the net after it. If the net does not clear, the recommendation is stay. How those ten days are spent is on the process page.
The only cost to you is pulling together drawings and annual quantities. The test is the same one this post runs, applied to your parts.
What to do with this
- Run each candidate through the landed-cost calculator, which adds the 10% fee to every alternative and none to your current cost. The inputs and the limits are in how to run a part through a landed-cost calculator.
- Check the part’s row in the break-even table. If the alternative’s FOB premium is past the line for its class, freight has to make up the gap; on the gasket and the enclosure the freight difference was worth 3 to 9 cents a unit.
- Estimate switching cost and divide it by the annual net. A payback measured in years is a stay.
- Send the parts that clear the line for factory-level quotes with the fee included.
Want this run on your parts? Send up to five SKUs and you’ll have a landed-cost comparison — China and other countries, named factories — in ten business days. No fee, no obligation.