Part of the guide: Supplier quality
· 7 min read · factory audit · quality

What a 40-point factory audit actually checks, and what it can't

A 40-point audit tests whether a factory is real, owns its floor, controls its process and will last. What each group of checks looks for, the red flags, and why one day on site never replaces the FAI or inspection.

A factory audit answers one question before any purchase order: is this a real factory that can make this kind of part, repeatably, and still be here next year? It does not answer whether your part will pass, and a buyer who treats the audit report as a quality guarantee has misread what the day on site can see.

This post walks through what the 40 points cover, grouped the way an auditor actually works the floor, what evidence answers each group, and the limits of a single visit. The audit is the first of six checkpoints; how it fits with the golden sample, the in-process check, the AQL inspection and the rest is in the supplier quality guide.

Verification is not the audit

Before anyone travels, a desk check filters the candidates: business registration, export records, references, and whether the registered address is a factory or an office. It takes a few hours and removes the candidates that would waste a day on site.

The audit is the on-site visit, with photographs, before a factory is quoted to you. It is the qualification stage of the five-stage process, alongside the capacity check, the NNN agreement and the certification map for each SKU.

A desk check tells you a company exists. Only the visit tells you what is on its floor.

The seven groups, and what each one is for

The 40 points on the site’s checklist cover business license and legal identity, ownership, production equipment and capacity, the quality management system and its records, incoming inspection, calibration, engineering capability, the sub-supplier list, working conditions and social compliance, and financial stability signals. On the floor they fall naturally into seven groups. The table below is a working checklist by group, not a count of points per group.

GroupWhat the auditor looks atEvidence that answers itRed flag
Business legitimacy and ownershipBusiness license, legal name, registered scope, who owns the building and the machinesLicense matches the entity on the quote; scope covers manufacturing; equipment invoices or asset records in the same nameLicense names a trading company; the “factory” is introduced as a partner or a sister company
Capacity and equipmentMachine list against the floor, tonnage or spindle count, shifts, current loadingMachines on the list are on the floor with work under them; a capacity figure that survives arithmeticIdle lines staged for the visit; capacity claimed with one shift and no spare press
Process controlWork instructions at the station, setup records, first-piece approval on the line, how a process change is approvedWritten instructions in the operators’ language, matching the part being run; signed setup sheetsInstructions that exist only in the office; no record of who approved the last change
Quality system and recordsQC records for recent shipments, nonconformance log, calibration of gauges, final inspectionLast month’s records describe parts the floor is actually running; calibration stickers match the logRecords that are all passes; a calibration log with no dates newer than the certificate on the wall
Materials and subcontractingIncoming inspection, material traceability, the sub-supplier list for plating, painting, heat treatment and similarIncoming lots tagged and logged; a named sub-supplier for every process the factory does not do itselfA process the factory cannot do in-house and will not name a supplier for
Social and environmental complianceWorking conditions, hours and pay records, dormitories if any, fire safety, discharge and waste handling where the process creates themRecords consistent with what the floor shows; exits clear; permits on file for processes that need themTwo sets of time records; a plating or paint line with no paperwork for its waste
Financial stabilitySignals rather than audited accounts: order book, payroll regularity, condition of the plant, how long the factory has held the siteSteady staffing, maintained equipment, customers the factory will describeUnpaid-wage notices, equipment pledged as collateral, a recent move with no reason given

Read the table by its last column. Each red flag is a failure that would otherwise surface after the first order.

Ownership is the answer to read first

Of everything in the report, the ownership answer changes the most downstream. If the counterparty is a trading company presenting a factory, the floor you were shown may not be the floor that makes your part, your drawing travels further than you intended, and the quote carries a margin you cannot see.

The auditor tests ownership with documents that are hard to borrow: the business license against the entity on the quote, equipment invoices in the same name, payroll for the people on the floor, and the utility account for the building.

A trading company is not a bad counterparty on its own. It is a different one, with different answers to who holds title, who sets the price and who you can fire, which are set out in sourcing agent versus trading company.

Find the ownership line in the report before you read anything else.

What a good audit actually tests: consistency

An audit is not a tour. An ISO 9001 certificate on the wall tells you a quality system was assessed at some point, not that it is being followed this week. What the auditor is really testing is whether the documents and the floor agree: the calibration sticker against the calibration log, last month’s QC records against the parts on the line, the machine list against the machines with chips under them, the sub-supplier list against the plated parts in the incoming area.

Suppose a buyer’s audit finds a full binder of inspection records, every one a pass, and an incoming area with no inspection tags on any lot. The binder is a document; the incoming area is the process. That observation is worth more than a page of photographs of clean floors.

Ask for the photographs behind each finding, not only the score. A score tells you the result; the photos tell you what the auditor saw.

What a one-day audit cannot do

It is a snapshot. The factory knew the auditor was coming. The line you saw may be the best line on its best shift, and the records you read are the ones the factory chose to keep.

It cannot prove future performance. A factory that passes in March can change its resin supplier in June or fill the presses you were counting on with another customer’s work. The monthly scorecard, with on-time and defect rate per PO, is what watches the trend.

It does not measure your part. An audit looks at capability across the factory. Whether your part, with your tolerances and your material, comes off the tool correctly is the job of the first-article inspection against your drawing, and the appearance standard is set by the golden sample. Both are described in golden samples and first-article inspection.

It does not replace inspection. The in-process check at 20–30% of the run and the AQL pre-shipment inspection happen on every order, against the approved sample. A factory that passed its audit last year still has its lots sampled this month.

It answers the question of whoever commissioned it. An audit paid for by the party selling you the parts was written for a different reader than one done on your behalf. Read the report knowing who it was for.

The audit is included in the 10% fee along with the inspections, as the pricing page sets out, and because you pay the factory directly, nobody in the audit decision profits from a pass. The full checkpoint list it belongs to is on the quality and inspection page.

The audit is the reason you are willing to place the first order. It is not the reason you release any shipment.

What to do with this

  1. Find the last audit report for each active factory and note who commissioned it and when. A report older than your current tooling, or written for someone else, is not your baseline.
  2. Read the ownership answer first. If the report does not say plainly whether the entity on your PO owns the floor, that is the first question to send back.
  3. Check the report for consistency findings, not only a score. Calibration against the log, records against the floor, sub-suppliers named. A report with none of these is a tour, not an audit.
  4. Do not let a passed audit stand in for the FAI or the inspection plan. Write down which checkpoint covers your part, which covers the run, and which covers the lot.

If the current factory has never been audited, that is the first thing a re-quote fixes. Send us the SKUs — ten business days, no fee, and the audit report is yours either way.

Free 10-day re-quote

Send us your top five SKUs. Get every viable origin back.

No commitment. In ten business days you’ll have a landed-cost comparison you can put in front of your CFO, with named factories behind every number.