Part of the guide: Landed cost and tariffs
· 6 min read · landed cost · pricing

FOB vs. landed cost: the factory price is the number that matters least

In the gasket example FOB spans $1.20 to $1.38 while duty spans $0.48 to $0.00, and the dearest factory lands cheapest. What FOB covers, what landed and all-in cost add, and where supplier quote comparisons go wrong.

The factory price is the number buyers compare first and the one that decides least. In the gasket example below, FOB spans $1.20 to $1.38 across China and two alternative origins while duty spans $0.48 to $0.00, and the origin with the most expensive factory lands cheapest by 11% after the agent fee.

This post is about that gap: what an FOB quote actually includes, what landed and all-in cost add to it, and where quote comparisons go wrong. The full line-by-line method, with freight, working capital and the tariff stack by class, is in the landed-cost guide for importers, 2026 edition. Every rate here is as of September 26, 2026 and confirmed per HTS code in a re-quote.

What FOB covers, and what it leaves out

FOB is an Incoterms rule, and like the others it answers one question: at what point cost and risk pass from seller to buyer. Under FOB the factory’s price includes getting the goods to the named port of origin, export-cleared and loaded; from that point freight, insurance, duty and delivery are yours. EXW (ex works) moves the handover back to the factory door, so the quoted price is lower and you also pay inland haulage and export clearance you may not have budgeted. DDP (delivered duty paid) moves it forward to your dock, so the price looks complete, but freight and duty are buried inside it at the seller’s rates and margin, and you cannot see which line moved when the price changes.

For a comparison between origins, FOB is the useful term because it separates the factory from everything after the factory. An EXW quote understates the cost; a DDP quote hides its composition. If you receive quotes on different terms, convert them to FOB before you line them up, or you are comparing three different things.

One more reason FOB is the right base: in the US, customs value for an FOB purchase is essentially the FOB price, since international freight and insurance are not dutiable. Every percentage in the duty stack multiplies this number. A 40% duty on $1.20 is 48 cents; get the base wrong by ten cents and the duty line is off by four cents a unit before you have compared anything.

The gasket: FOB moves 15 percent, duty moves to zero

Molded EPDM gasket, HTS 4016.93.50 (MFN 2.5%, Section 301 List 3), 120,000 units a year, freight to Dallas. Rates as of September 26, 2026, confirmed per HTS code.

Per unitChinaAlt. origin · 12.5% dutyAlt. origin · FTA, 0%
FOB$1.20$1.26$1.38
Duty$0.48 (40.0%)$0.19 (15.0%)$0.00 (0%)
Freight$0.06$0.07$0.03
Landed$1.74$1.52$1.41
Our fee, 10% of FOB—$0.13$0.14
All-in$1.74$1.65$1.55
Annual, all-in$208,800$197,520$185,760

Read the first row against the second. FOB climbs from $1.20 to $1.38, 18 cents, 15% end to end. Duty falls from $0.48 to $0.00. The duty line swings 48 cents, more than two and a half times the FOB swing, and in the opposite direction.

The China rate is MFN 2.5% plus 25% on List 3 plus the 12.5% from the July 24, 2026 Section 301 action, 40.0% in total. The 12.5% origin pays MFN plus 12.5%, 15.0%. The FTA-qualifying origin pays nothing once the rule of origin is documented for the heading.

A buyer comparing factory quotes alone would rank these origins China first, then the 12.5% origin, then the FTA origin, and would be exactly backwards. Landed, the order reverses: $1.74, $1.52, $1.41. Add the 10% fee to each alternative and the FTA origin still wins at $1.55 all-in, $23,040 a year, 11% after the fee, with the 12.5% origin at $1.65, $11,280 (5.4%).

The lesson generalizes. On a Section 301 List 1–3 heading, China pays MFN plus 37.5 points as of September 26, 2026, against MFN plus 12.5 at a 12.5% origin and 0% at an FTA-qualifying one. On the $1.20 gasket that is 48 cents of duty against zero, so the FTA origin’s factory could charge up to $1.68 and still land level on those two lines before freight and the fee. How those points are built, class by class, is in how to read your tariff stack by HTS code.

What an all-in comparison must include

Landed cost is FOB plus duty plus freight to your dock. All-in cost adds whatever you pay to get the alternative found, qualified and managed. A comparison that leaves out any of these is not conservative; it is wrong in a direction you cannot predict.

  • FOB per origin, on the same Incoterms term, from a named factory with the MOQ behind the price.
  • Duty per HTS code per origin, as the full stack: MFN, any China list rate, the July 24 Section 301 layer, Section 232 where the part is metal, and the FTA status checked per part.
  • Freight per unit to your dock, including insurance, terminal and drayage charges, and the Merchandise Processing Fee and Harbor Maintenance Fee collected at entry.
  • The agent fee, on its own line. Ours is 10% of FOB, invoiced per PO, no retainer, no setup fee, no minimum; the terms are on the pricing page. It is on every alternative in the table above, which is why the 11% is a net figure and not a gross one. Whether the fee pays for itself on a given part has a numeric answer, worked in does a 10% sourcing fee pay for itself.

Compare the incumbent’s landed cost to each alternative’s all-in cost. That is the only comparison in which a 10% saving is a 10% saving.

What buyers get wrong when comparing supplier quotes

The first mistake is comparing quotes on different terms. An EXW quote from one factory and an FOB quote from another differ by inland freight and export handling before either part has moved an inch. Ask every factory for FOB at the named port and the comparison starts level.

The second is applying one duty rate to every origin. The MFN rate in the HTSUS is the same regardless of origin, so it is tempting to add it once and move on. In 2026 the MFN rate is the smallest layer. The China list rate, the July 24 layer and the FTA waiver are where the origins diverge, and all three depend on the 8-digit code.

The third is freight per container instead of per unit. A container quote looks like a single big number and gets divided roughly, or ignored, or copied from a different part. The gasket’s freight is three to seven cents a unit because many thousands fit in a container; a bulky enclosure in the same container might carry a dollar a unit. Freight belongs on the sheet per unit, by lane, which is the subject of freight per unit, not per container.

The fourth is leaving the fee off the alternative and the quality cost off the incumbent. If a sourcing agent found the new factory, the fee is part of the new factory’s cost. If the current factory ships without a pre-shipment inspection, the rework and returns are part of the current factory’s cost, even when they land in a different budget line. Both belong on the same sheet.

The fifth is assuming an FTA origin is a 0% origin. The 0% is earned per part by meeting the rule of origin for the heading; a part that fails it pays MFN + 10%. A quote that shows 0% without a rule-of-origin check is showing you a hope.

What to do with this

  1. Convert every quote you hold to FOB at the port of origin before comparing anything. Ask the factory to restate it if necessary.
  2. Build the four lines for each origin: FOB, duty per HTS code, freight per unit, and the fee. Try it in the landed-cost calculator with your actual numbers.
  3. Compare the incumbent’s landed cost against each alternative’s all-in cost, and treat anything under 5% as a tie to be decided on lead time, MOQ and risk.

How a re-quote assembles these lines in ten business days, from the SKU list to the named factory, is on the process page.

Try your own numbers in the landed-cost calculator, then send us the five SKUs you’d most like re-quoted. Ten business days, no fee.

Free 10-day re-quote

Send us your top five SKUs. Get every viable origin back.

No commitment. In ten business days you’ll have a landed-cost comparison you can put in front of your CFO, with named factories behind every number.